Our 1970s Baseball All-Decade Team

The 1970s was a golden era for baseball, filled with legendary players, unforgettable games, and significant developments in the sport. The decade was marked by the emergence of new stars, the continuation of old rivalries, and a unique blend of traditional and modern styles of play.

In this section, we’ll take a brief stroll down memory lane to set the stage for our All-Decade Team selection.

The 1970s: A Baseball Odyssey

The 1970s witnessed the rise of some of the most iconic figures in baseball history. Players like Pete Rose, Reggie Jackson, and Nolan Ryan became household names. It was a time when the “Big Red Machine” dominated, the Yankees returned to glory, and the underdog Pirates clinched the World Series in a dramatic fashion.

Moreover, the decade saw the inception of the designated hitter rule in the American League, which added a new strategic layer to the game.

It was also a time of notable stylistic diversity, with power hitters, speedsters, and tactical players all leaving their mark on the sport. The ’70s also had its fair share of controversies, which only added to the drama and the narrative of baseball during this time.

Selecting the All-Decade Team

Creating an All-Decade Team is not an easy feat, especially given the wealth of talent that graced the fields during the 1970s.

Our selection is based on a careful analysis of players’ performance, consistency, and contributions to their respective teams throughout the decade. We’ve considered their statistics, the number of accolades they received, and their performances in crucial games.

We’ve chosen the best player for each position, making sure to consider both their defensive and offensive capabilities. Following that, we’ve also selected the next 9 best players of the decade, regardless of their positions, to honor the true legends of the ’70s.

Through this nostalgic venture, we aim to celebrate the legacy of the 1970s baseball era and the remarkable individuals who made it an unforgettable chapter in sports history. Our list might bring back some fond memories, spark debates, or even introduce you to the greats you might not have known about.

Best Player for Each Position: The Starters

Pitcher: Tom Seaver

Tom Seaver, fondly known as “Tom Terrific,” was the epitome of a dominant pitcher during the 1970s. His precision on the mound, coupled with his ability to deliver under pressure, made him a nightmare for batters.

Seaver bagged multiple Cy Young Awards throughout the decade, with remarkable performances that included an unforgettable no-hitter in 1978. His enduring prowess and consistency have cemented his status as one of the finest pitchers of the era.

Catcher: Johnny Bench

Johnny Bench’s name is synonymous with catching excellence. His defensive prowess behind the plate was unparalleled, and his offensive contributions were equally impressive.

Bench collected a series of Gold Gloves and All-Star appearances in the ’70s, displaying a blend of skill, agility, and power. His clutch performance in the 1976 World Series showcased his ability to shine in crucial moments, making him the clear choice for the catcher position.

First Base: Rod Carew

Rod Carew was a master at the plate, known for his exceptional batting average and ability to get on base. His finesse and technique made him one of the most feared hitters of the 1970s.

Carew’s 1972 batting title with a remarkable .318 average and his near pursuit of a .400 average in 1977 are testaments to his offensive genius. His consistent performances and the elegance with which he played the game made him the obvious choice for the first base position.

Second Base: Joe Morgan

Joe Morgan was a powerhouse in a compact frame, excelling both offensively and defensively. His blend of speed, power, and on-field intelligence made him a cornerstone of the Cincinnati Reds’ “Big Red Machine” dynasty. Throughout the ’70s, Morgan racked up multiple All-Star appearances and Gold Glove awards, showcasing his all-around ability. His pivotal role in securing back-to-back World Series titles for the Reds in 1975 and 1976 underscores his significance in this era, making him the standout second baseman of the decade.

Third Base: Mike Schmidt

Mike Schmidt’s impact on the hot corner was nothing short of extraordinary during the 1970s. Known for his powerful bat and stellar defense, Schmidt was a force to reckon with. He collected numerous Gold Glove awards and was a frequent name in All-Star rosters throughout the decade.

His ability to change the game with a single swing or a defensive gem made him a hallmark figure at third base, establishing him as the premier player at the position during this era.

Shortstop: Dave Concepcion

Dave Concepcion was a linchpin in the Reds’ infield, bringing a blend of slick fielding and timely hitting. His defensive wizardry earned him multiple Gold Glove awards during the ’70s, while his clutch hitting in big moments was a testament to his well-rounded game.

Concepcion’s consistent excellence and pivotal role in the Reds’ championship successes make him the distinguished shortstop of the decade.

Left Field: Carl Yastrzemski

Carl Yastrzemski was a living legend in left field, with a stellar career that saw him excel in the ’70s. Known for his sweet swing and impeccable fielding, “Yaz” was a perennial All-Star and a key figure for the Boston Red Sox.

His leadership on and off the field, coupled with his ability to perform at a high level against the stiffest competition, makes him the standout choice for left field.

Center Field: Fred Lynn

Fred Lynn burst onto the scene in the ’70s with a blend of power, speed, and defensive acumen. His rookie year was historic, bagging both the Rookie of the Year and Most Valuable Player awards.

Throughout the decade, Lynn was a fixture in All-Star games and was known for his graceful yet effective patrolling of center field. His offensive and defensive contributions make him a clear choice for the center field position.

Right Field: Reggie Jackson

Reggie Jackson, also known as “Mr. October” for his postseason heroics, was a defining figure in right field during the ’70s. His power-hitting and flair for the dramatic made him a central figure in the baseball narrative of the decade.

Jackson’s unforgettable three-home-run game in the 1977 World Series is etched in baseball lore, showcasing his ability to shine on the biggest stage. His overall impact on the game during the ’70s makes him the undisputed choice for right field.

Selection of the Next 9 Best Players Overall

After identifying the top players for each position, we delved into the task of pinpointing the next 9 remarkable players from the 1970s, transcending positional boundaries. This list honors those whose contributions were pivotal in shaping the baseball narrative during this era.

A. Overview of the Selection Process

The journey to pick these players involved a thorough examination of their performance, versatility, and the indelible marks they left on the hearts of fans and the game itself.

The Next 9 Best: The Bench

1. Steve Carlton (Pitcher): Carlton’s left arm was a legend-maker, with numerous Cy Young Awards and a knack for strikeouts, establishing him as a pitching titan of the ’70s.
2. Jim Palmer (Pitcher): Palmer’s consistency and ability to perform in clutch situations made him a cornerstone of the Orioles’ success during this decade.
3. George Brett (Third Base): Brett’s exceptional hitting and solid defense were instrumental for the Royals, making him a standout third baseman of the era.
4. Willie Stargell (Left Field/First Base): Stargell’s power at the plate and leadership for the Pirates were legendary, making a lasting impact throughout the ’70s.
5. Fergie Jenkins (Pitcher): Jenkins was a workhorse on the mound, showcasing precision pitching and remarkable durability, hallmarks of his illustrious career.
6. Bobby Grich (Second Base): With a blend of power, defense, and consistency, Grich was a key figure at second base, contributing significantly to his team’s success.
7. Catfish Hunter (Pitcher): Hunter’s name is synonymous with pitching excellence in the ’70s, with multiple All-Star appearances and a perfect game to his name.
8. Lou Brock (Left Field): Brock’s speed and ability to get on base were unparalleled, making him a significant threat on the base paths throughout the decade.
9. Rollie Fingers (Relief Pitcher): Fingers’ trademark mustache was as recognizable as his pitching prowess, with his clutch performances in the bullpen being a hallmark of the ’70s baseball scene.

These athletes, with their unique blend of talent and character, contributed significantly to the rich tapestry of baseball during the 1970s. Through their exemplary performances, they helped script many unforgettable chapters in the annals of the sport.

Discussion

The 1970s stand out in baseball history with its mix of traditional play and modern strategies, like the introduction of the designated hitter rule. This era showcased a blend of talents, from power hitters to speedsters, providing a rich tapestry of baseball artistry.

The ’70s had a unique flavor compared to the power-dominant ’90s or pitching-centric ’60s, offering a diverse display of baseball skills and strategies that shaped the game’s evolution.

Notable Omissions

Some exceptional players like Ron Guidry and Thurman Munson didn’t make the cut for the All-Decade Team, showcasing the depth of talent during this era and sparking debates on selections.

Legacy and Impact

The chosen players for the 1970s All-Decade Team left a lasting legacy, setting high standards in their positions and inspiring subsequent generations with their remarkable performances and love for the game. Through their enduring impact, they continue to hold a special place in the hearts of baseball enthusiasts.

Conclusion

The 1970s was a remarkable chapter in baseball history, marked by players who brought a blend of grit, skill, and innovation to the field. Our All-Decade Team is a tribute to these legends whose impact transcended beyond the diamond, leaving a lasting legacy in the annals of the sport.

Finally, we invite you to reminisce about these players, share your own thoughts, and perhaps introduce us to your personal favorites from this era in the comments below.