Best First Basemen in Colorado Rockies History

The Five Best Rockies First Basemen of All-Time

The Colorado Rockies are a relatively young team in the grand scheme of Major League Baseball, having made their debut in 1993. Since their inception, they’ve become a beloved part of Denver’s vibrant sports scene. They play their home games at the iconic Coors Field, known for its picturesque view of the Rocky Mountains and its high altitude that tends to favor hitters.

Over the years, they’ve had their share of ups and downs but have produced memorable moments that have solidified their place in the hearts of their fans.

The Cornerstone: First Basemen

In baseball, every position on the field has its unique importance, but the first baseman holds a special place. They’re often the cornerstone of the infield. A first baseman is usually involved in a majority of the plays, whether they’re catching throws from other infielders to get outs or snagging line drives headed down the baseline.

Additionally, a great first baseman often brings a powerful bat to the lineup, making them a dual threat on offense and defense. Their contribution is vital for the team’s success, making them fan favorites and often leaders within the team.

How We Chose Our Top 5

Selecting the best of the best is no easy feat, especially when it comes to a position as crucial as the first baseman.

We based our picks on a combination of factors to ensure a well-rounded analysis. The criteria include offensive and defensive statistics, which provide a quantitative measure of a player’s performance. Longevity with the team speaks to a player’s consistency and loyalty, while leadership showcases their impact in the clubhouse and on the field.

Lastly, we looked at how each player contributed to the team’s success during their tenure, because at the end of the day, baseball is a team sport, and contributing to wins is what really counts.

In the following sections, we’ll count down the top five first basemen who have left an indelible mark on the Colorado Rockies’ franchise history. Each of these players brought something unique to the table, and their exploits on the field have earned them a place in the annals of Rockies’ lore.

So, whether you’re a die-hard Rockies fan or a casual baseball enthusiast, stay tuned as we reminisce about the stellar careers of these remarkable players.

Ben Paulsen (2014-2016): The Emerging Talent

Ben Paulsen might not have the lengthy resume as some of his counterparts, but his performance during his time with the Rockies was promising. Within a relatively short MLB career spanning from 2014 to 2016, Paulsen showcased potential, especially in the 2015 season where he played in 116 games.

Key Performance

His 2015 season slash line of .277/.326/.462, along with 11 home runs and 49 RBI, hinted at a burgeoning talent. These numbers reflect a balanced blend of hitting for average, power, and clutch performance.

Though Paulsen might not have the star-studded accolades as others on this list, his contribution to the Rockies during his tenure was noteworthy and presented a glimpse of what could have been a bright future in the MLB.

Mark Reynolds (2016-17, ’19): The Mountain’s Might

Mark Reynolds significantly contributed to the Colorado Rockies during his time with the team, especially in the 2016 and 2017 seasons. In 2016, he boasted a batting average of .282, a slugging percentage of .450, and contributed 14 home runs and 53 RBIs in 393 at-bats. He also hit the third-longest home run in MLB that year at 484 feet.

Key Performance:

The 2017 season was especially noteworthy for Reynolds. He belted 30 home runs and drove in 97 RBI, numbers that came tantalizingly close to earning him an All-Star recognition. Reynolds’ near All-Star season kept fans on the edge of their seats and cemented his legacy as a formidable first baseman for the Rockies.

Justin Morneau (2014-15): The Northern Star

Though Justin Morneau’s time with the Rockies was brief, spanning only from 2014 to 2015, he made his presence felt with every swing. His batting slash line of .316/.363/.487 over 184 games illustrated his ability to blend power with precision.

Key Performance

Morneau’s crowning achievement came in 2014 when he clinched the National League batting title with a stellar .319 average.

Winning a batting title is no small feat—it’s a hallmark of a player’s ability to outperform peers over the long and grueling MLB season. Justin Morneau’s achievement placed him in a distinguished list of hitters and marked his name in the Rockies’ history.

Andres Galarraga (1994-97): The Big Cat

Andres Galarraga, affectionately known as “The Big Cat” due to his agility, only had a 5-year stint with the Rockies but left a lasting impact. Galarraga was the RBI king of the National League in 1996 and 1997, driving in a whopping 150 and 140 runs respectively.

Galarraga clinched the NL batting title in 1993, boasting a remarkable .370 average, which is a feat that speaks volumes about his batting excellence.


Galarraga was a key figure during the Blake Street Bombers era, a time in the mid-90s when the Rockies lineup was feared due to its power-hitting capabilities.

The Big Cat was part of this intimidating offensive brigade, and his contributions went a long way in putting the Rockies on the map during those years. His powerful swings and consistent performance made games thrilling to watch, and his legacy as one of the Rockies’ best first basemen continues to be celebrated by fans.

Todd Helton (1997-2013): The Cornerstone of the Rockies

Todd Helton is a name that resonates with every Rockies fan. With a stellar career spanning from 1997 to 2013, Helton has etched his name into the Rockies’ history books. His WAR (Wins Above Replacement) of 61.8 isn’t just a number, but a testament to his indispensable value to the team.

For those new to baseball metrics, WAR essentially measures a player’s contribution to their team in terms of wins. A higher WAR indicates a player’s ability to replace a lesser player, translating to more wins for the team.

His accolades include being a five-time All-Star, a four-time Silver Slugger Award winner, and a three-time Gold Glove Award winner.

Key Performance

The 2000 season was one of the best seasons for any player in baseball history. He led the National League in several key offensive categories: batting average (.372), on-base percentage (.463), slugging percentage (.698), hits (216), doubles (59), and runs batted in (147)​.

Helton’s performance that season made him the first player in the National League to achieve at least 200 hits, 40 home runs, 100 RBI, 100 runs, 100 extra-base hits, and 100 walks in a single season.


The history of the Colorado Rockies is enriched by the contributions of these first basemen, each bringing a unique blend of skill, determination, and charisma to the field. Through the ups and downs, their performances have etched memorable moments into the hearts of Rockies fans and baseball aficionados alike.

As we reflect on the legacies of Todd Helton, Andres Galarraga, Justin Morneau, Mark Reynolds, and Ben Paulsen, we also turn our gaze toward the future.

Who will be the next to step up to the plate and carve their name into the Rockies’ first base legacy?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *